This fresh, homemade Crockpot Spaghetti Sauce is a delicious meatless sauce made from scratch. This sugar-free spaghetti sauce creates magic from fresh tomatoes and herbs.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Have you ever thought “can I make spaghetti sauce in a crockpot” to yourself? Well, the good news is that yes, you sure can!
The slow cooker heats evenly and gently and does its thing without burning the sauce. Pure magic my friends. Pure magic.
Prefer to use canned tomatoes to make marinara sauce? If so, check out this Freezer Spaghetti Sauce that uses canned goods and pantry staples.
What Kind of Tomatoes Work Best in Crockpot Spaghetti Sauce?
Heartier paste-style tomatoes are the easiest to work with for this recipe. They are easy to peel and have fewer seeds. They also have a lower moisture content which means they take less time to cook down.
But sometimes you (ok, it’s me) have 18 different tomato plants that are all ripening at the same time and you need to do something with them. This slow cooker marinara is the perfect home for those random tomatoes.
If you are using tomatoes that are more suitable for sandwiches (AKA “slicers”), you’ll want to mix them with some paste-style tomatoes for the sauce to reduce/thicken.
Only have cherry tomatoes? Check out our recipe for Cherry Tomato Sauce.
If you’re a canner, check out these posts on Canning Tomatoes {Whole tomatoes} and Canning Stewed Tomatoes because both can help you make amazing homemade spaghetti sauce on the fly.
Do I Have to Peel Tomatoes To Make Sauce?
You don’t have to, but it will impact the overall texture of your finished sauce if you don’t. You can read more about it in this in-depth tutorial on How to Blanch and Peel Tomatoes.
Don’t want to take that extra step? I got you covered. Cut the tomatoes in half, push the seeds out with your thumb and then grate the tomato using a box grater, discarding the skins. It’s not foolproof as some skin will still get mixed in, but that’s ok.
You can also use frozen tomatoes (related: Freezing Tomatoes). The amazing part about using frozen tomatoes is that you can allow them to thaw in a bowl overnight and the skins will slip right off!
How Long Will This Sauce Last in the Fridge?
This sauce does not contain preservatives, and I would only feel safe about storing it in the fridge for 2-3 days.
How to Freeze Spaghetti Sauce
You can freeze this sauce in a wide-mouth canning jar. Make sure to leave 1 inch of space between the top of the sauce and the top of the jar to allow for expansion during freezing.
Check out this post on Canning Supplies for my favorite sources for cheap or free canning jars.
If you don’t have canning jars, I love to use these 2-cup Souper Cubes for freezing my sauce. Remove the frozen sauce and transfer it to freezer-safe storage.
You can also use freezer bags to freeze the marinara sauce. Allow sauce to fully cool and transfer to a quart or gallon-size bag. Don’t overfill and gently remove additional air. Freeze flat and then you can store it upright.
Spaghetti sauce will keep in the freezer for 6-9 months.
Can This Spaghetti Sauce Be Canned?
This recipe has not been tested for a safe PH balance, and therefore it is not considered safe for canning. I only recommend freezing it for long-term storage.
Pro Tips/Recipe Notes
- I used my Instant Pot on the slow cooker function with the slow cooker lid for this recipe.
- If you want a less chunky sauce, pulse it a few times with an immersion blender or mash it a bit with a potato masher or large spoon. Add the baking soda, salt and pepper, and additional herbs to taste.
- The (optional) baking soda is a great way to neutralize the natural acidity of tomatoes without adding additional sugar.
- Making this all day and then refrigerating it overnight gives it an extra kick of awesome in the flavor department.
- Try it for a dipping sauce for Air Fryer Ravioli, or use it in this Ravioli Bake. I also use 2 tbsp of it as the secret ingredient in my Whole30 Pot Roast.
- Want to up the veggie factor? Sneak in some frozen pumpkin. No one will know!
- Feel free to add meat if you’d like. Just make sure you fully cook it before incorporating it into the sauce.
WEIGHT WATCHERS POINTS
One serving has 0 WW Freestyle SmartPoints.
Crockpot Spaghetti Sauce {Sugar-Free Spaghetti Sauce}
Ingredients
Instructions
- Rinse tomatoes and core them. Drop tomatoes in a pot of boiling water for one minute.10 cups tomatoes
- Scoop tomatoes out with a slotted spoon and place in a bowl of ice water. Now the skins will slip off easily.
- Cut in half (quarters for larger tomatoes) and push out the seeds out with your thumb.
- Add the tomatoes and all the ingredients (except baking soda and tomato paste) to the slow cooker.2 tbsp fresh basil, 1 tbsp fresh oregano, 1 tbsp fresh parsley, 6 cloves garlic, 1 cup onion, 6 oz canned tomato paste
- Cook on low for 10 hours or high for 7 hours. Stir occasionally if possible. The sauce should be reduced by about half.
- If you want a less chunky sauce, pulse it a few times with an immersion blender or mash it a bit with a potato masher or large spoon. Add the canned tomato paste at this point if you’d like a thicker sauce.
- Add the baking soda (it will foam a bit), salt and pepper, and additional herbs to taste.1/8 tsp baking soda, salt and pepper to taste
Notes
- Making this all day and then refrigerating it overnight gives it an extra kick of awesome in the flavor department.
- The (optional) baking soda is a great way to neutralize the natural acidity of tomatoes without adding additional sugar.
- You can freeze this sauce in a wide-mouth canning jar. Make sure to leave 1 inch of space between the top of the sauce and the top of the jar to allow for expansion during freezing.
Shop this Post:
(may include affiliate links)
Do you cook this with the lid on ? I cooked it for 10 hours and it’s really watery.
Hi Loretta, I do cook it with the lid on. Tell me more about the tomatoes you used. Were they roma? Beefsteak, etc.? The types of tomatoes you use will impact the overall texture of the sauce.
Since you have already cooked it for 10 hours, you can do one of two things. 1) add 1-2 cans of tomato paste, and cook for another hour 2) siphon some of the water from the sides of the crockpot until the consistency is one that you like. I’d use a small measuring cup for this.
Can you please clarify when to add the optional tomato paste. It is listed in step 4 as well as step 6 of the recipe.
Thank you!
Hi Laura, great question. I’ll update the post to be more clear.
I’d recommend it in step 6, since if you added it earlier, you may not love the texture. With doing it in step 6, you’re more in control of the final texture.
Can this sauce be canned?
Hi Cindy, this recipe has not been tested for a safe PH balance, and therefore it is not considered safe for canning.